Politics is about democracy, or it is nothing. If voters lose trust in democracy, a country can embark on a very slippery slope indeed. We are at the top of that slope right now, and if slopes can have precipices, then we’re looking over the edge right now. Let me explain why.

On 23 June 2016, more people voted to leave the European Union than had ever voted for a single political party in this country. 17.4 million people gave their government a mandate to negotiate our exit from an organisation we had joined 43 years earlier. Like any divorce, the parting was bound to be painful. And it was. The ensuing four years were bitter, divisive and showed our politicians at their worst.

And now, it seems, we are going to do it all over again, thanks to our new prime minister.

Andy Burnham was not in parliament during those years. He had scarpered off to Manchester after spending one year and 22 days in Jeremy Corbyn’s shadow cabinet as shadow home secretary. He wasn’t there for all the shenanigans regarding Theresa May’s doomed deal or Boris Johnson’s prorogation of Parliament.

It was an act of courage when Andy Burnham announced he would stand in the Makerfield by-election. Let’s remember it voted 65% in favour of leaving the EU. He knew he had to get those voters to back him if he was to prevail. And he did. Let’s remind ourselves how.

On 18 May, at the Great North Investment Summit, Burnham said this. “My view is that Brexit has been damaging, but I also believe the last thing we should do right now is re-run those arguments.” He could not have been clearer. No ifs. No buts. Later in the same speech, he said he wasn’t proposing that the UK consider rejoining the EU and that he respected the referendum result. He added: “It’s going to undermine everything that I’ve said about strengthening democracy if we don’t respect that vote.” Quite.

Yet only four months later, he intentionally reopened the Eu debate in his speech to the Labour Party conference, and less than two months later came to an agreement with the EU which does none of the things he claims it does.

And it is clear that rejoining the EU is very firmly back on the table.

I recognise that times change. I recognise that we live in a different world to that which existed in 2016, or even 2020, when we formally left the EU. However, the arguments for being outside the EU are fundamentally the same. Being outside the EU did not prevent the UK from leading the European response to the invasion of Ukraine. Full sovereignty was restored to the UK Parliament. The fact that our politicians have failed to utilise that sovereignty to deregulate and abolish many of the needless EU regulations that hamper our businesses is not the fault of Brexit.

We were told by the Remain campaign in 2016 that an economic apocalypse would ensue if we left. We were told unemployment would rise to more than five million. It actually continued to fall. We were told big financial firms would leave the city of London for Frankfurt or Paris. Only J P Morgan did, to any meaningful degree, and even they, after a few years, admitted it had been a mistake and announced they were returning to London.

We were told our services sector would be damaged by coming out of the EU. The City of London (the Square Mile) had 740,000 jobs in 2024, the latest year in the ONS’s total jobs series, compared with 586,000 in 2016. That’s 154,000 more jobs, an increase of 26.3%. The City of London Corporation’s November 2026 briefing uses a narrower business survey measure. On that basis, employment rose from 488,800 in September 2016 to 676,000 in September 2024, an increase of 187,200, or 38.3%.

We were told our economic activity and GDP would plummet. Our GDP growth (14.7%) since June 2016 has been higher than France (12.6%), Germany (8.0%), Italy (12,2%) and many other (but not all) EU member states.

It is perfectly possible to argue that if we had remained in the EU GDP would have been higher, as many people do. People use a figure of between 4 and 8%. People use this figure to imply our economy is 4-8% smaller. No. Smaller that it MIGHT otherwise have been. The trouble is, it’s an assertion which no one can prove.

As someone who voted Leave, and would do so again, I have absolutely no issue with getting closer to the EU on all sorts of issues. I recognise that we live in a different world, where the traditional international alliances and trading blocs are shifting. Our alliance with the United States cannot be relied on, certainly for the next two years, but possibly way beyond that. NATO is becoming increasingly irrelevant without the active participation and support of America. So in defence terms, whether we like it or not, more European cooperation is absolutely essential for our collective security. It makes total sense to remove some of the more intrusive trade barriers that were contained in the original so-called Free Trade Deal (it was, of course, nothing of the sort). But this cannot and should not happen if it means becoming a rule taker and where EU rules can be imposed on us without us having a proper say, by which I mean just being ‘in the room’ is not enough. Trade is more global than ever. Yes, most countries trade most with those who are geographically closest to them. Some people try to allege that our trade with the EU has been slashed since Brexit. In 2016 5.4% of our exports went to the Republic of Ireland. In the twelve months to June 2026 it was 5.8% -  a total of £54.6 billion. Exports to France have remained static at 5.1% of total exports since we left in 2020. Although trade with Germany has increased from £50.5 billion to £66.6 billion, the German share of exports has declined from 8.0% to 7.1%. Statistically, we can all choose the figures for each country to back up our case, but surely the following figures provide proof that our export trade with the EU has not collapsed. In 2016 42.8% of our exports went to the EU. In 2020 it was 41.1%. In the year to June 2026 it had fallen by 0.1% to 41%. On the imports side, it is a similar picture. In 2016 52.3 per cent of imports came from the EU. In 2020 the figure was 50% and to June 2026 it was 48.9%.

We have a very positive trade balance in Services with the EU, which has grown from £18 billion in 2016 to £48 billion in the year to 2026. However, the Goods deficit has grown from £91 billion to £142 billion. (All the figures quoted are from the Trade and Investment core statistics book from Gov.uk.)

Andy Burnham cites opinion polls showing a headline figure of 56-60 per cent of people wanting to rejoin the EU. He ignores the poll findings that show that when people are told it would be on far inferior terms to the previous ones that figure rapidly declines to well under 50 per cent. People wouldn’t accept a £30 billion net contribution, they don’t want to joint he euro and they certainly don’t want to join Schengen.

Andy Burnham promised to outline the options for our relations with the EU by Christmas. It’s a promise I suspect he already regrets making. If he had come out from the outset and said “I want Britain to rejoin the EU and here’s why”, that would be one way to start a Mrs Merton style heated debate, but to appear to follow public opinion rather than lead it is not what a prime minister is there to do. But it’s him all over. Throw some cards up in the air and see where they land.

In normal-speak, it’s an abrogation of political leadership, and he will live to regret it. People’s trust in politicians is already rock bottom. For Burnham to say that every one of his government’s policies must ‘pass the Makerfield test’ and then open up the Brexit debate again, is taking voters for fools. And voters don’t appreciate that. Ever.